• About
  • Digbeth event listings
  • Maps, photos and gubbins
  • The DiGpuss shop
  • Getgood Link: Police try to stop gangland movie being shown – One Eye on the Road

    Written by Nicky Getgood on Wednesday, November 4th, 2009 ( 5 responses )
    Tags: , , , , ,

    Police try to stop gangland movie being shown « One Eye on the Road – Be warned, the above film trailer ain’t pretty.  Apparently an attempted screening at the Custard Factory of the full-length version of 1 Day, a controversial film about gang culture in Birmingham, was halted by the police:

    Penny the director finally screened it in a place called the Custard Factory on a dvd. Police arrived 15 minutes into the screening and stopped it, turned on all the lights and came in to “count” the audience (all quietly watching the film). They also took the film crew’s details.

    When the police superintendent was challenged by Penny on Radio 5 Live the next morning, the superintendent claimed that her officers had attended “because we heard there were problems with the projector” (a startling claim in its own right, no less when there was actually no projector…).

    No-one can really figure out what has happened. It is deeply alarming that the police have suddenly switched sides and decided to actively censor the film by persuading cinema owners that public health and safety is at risk.

    It seems that the film is prevented from being screened across the West Midlands and many are shouting ‘censorship!’ But, as Danny Smith explains in his rather brilliant post about Birmingham’s gang culture, lifting this censorship could cause a whole heap of problems:

    I suspect a lot of the elements…will be discussed in the narrative and the more depressing points hid behind the same sort aggrandizing and protagonist empathy that the real message will be lost. No one will realise that these problems are real and happening to people’s sons and daughters every day.

    Another, more practical worry is that it seems that only members of one gang were chosen to appear in the film. Which to all intents and purposes becomes an elaborate version of the YouTube adverts and contains many of the ‘trophy’ members of that gang. Or, if you like, the gang members that do appear in the film will quickly become so called ‘trophy members’. This, many suspect, will draw a lot of negative reaction from the rival gangs, and the negative reaction will not just translate into poor box office figures and stern letters to The Guardian. There will be violence, and I suspect a lot of it.

    So perhaps the police could have handled the event at the Custard Factory better but, looking at the possible consequences of the widespread release of the film, you can kind of understand why this has happened.

    Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

    Comments:

    1

    The police quote in the Birmingham Post version of events tells a different story of events: “A force spokesman said: “The atmosphere was very positive and peaceful and the screening went ahead as planned.””

    There’s also a WM Police youtube video with their take on the film. They kinda don’t like it (more for negative stereotyping than anything).

    Of course the comments under the Youtube clips of the film are were the real action is taking place although there’s as much concern about a clip showing a street sign mistakenly showing an ‘E’ postcode (therefore London).

    2

    It’s also worth noting that it doesn’t seem “the police” warning off picture houses, more like “a copper”. That sounds a hell of a lot more dodgy. It’s hard not to picture him observing that the popcorn stand looks a bit flammable while he makes his insinuations of trouble.

    3

    Oh dear, this is what happens when you trust blogs over traditional media. ;-)

    My bad.

    But thanks for pointing me to that YouTube discussion Dave. That is truly frightening, and kind of proves Danny’s point.

    4

    Oh I dunno. I don’t think it proves anything. As evidence youtube comments are probably the least reliable of all.

    5
    John Heaven said:
    on November 13th, 2009

    I, too, can understand why they would want to stop this. Having said that, my objection is based entirely on the trailer, and that’s on YouTube for everyone to see.
    The thing that disturbs me about the trailer is that it gives the impression that this kind of violence is pervasive, and it leaves only one possible answer to the question ‘If I lived in the midst of this, which side would I rather be on?’.

    What is your opinion?










    @digbethisgood on Twitter

    RSS Feed

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Is Brum Happy?

    Brum's emotional wellbeing rating:
    subdued(-27)
    Twice daily updates via twitter - follow @birminghamuk

    Latest DiGpuss finds

    A photo on Flickr
    A photo on Flickr
    A photo on Flickr
    Wordpress theme offered by MyDaysOf.com